Skip to main content

Layered Defense: Prevention and Mitigation in Asset Integrity and Process Safety

Image
By


Layered Defense: Prevention and Mitigation in Asset Integrity and Process Safety






In the high-stakes worlds of Asset Integrity Management (AIM) and Process Safety Management (PSM), our goal is to operate safely and reliably. 




A key strategy in achieving this is the implementation of a layered defense, built upon the principles of Prevention and Mitigation.


Through Implementing principles of PSM, we aim to build layers of protection to stop incidents before they happen (Prevention) and to minimize the impact if they do (Mitigation).




Prevention: Stopping Incidents at the Source

In AIM and PSM, prevention is about being proactive. It involves:


  • Robust Design and Engineering: Selecting appropriate materials, designing for intended operating conditions, and ensuring sound engineering practices from the outset. This is the "Inherent Safe Plant Design" layer.

  • Strict Operating Procedures: Implementing and adhering to clear and safe work procedures ("Operations Procedures" in the Bowtie).

  • Regular Inspection and Maintenance: Proactively identifying and addressing potential degradation or failure mechanisms through scheduled inspections (like the Current Transformer (CT) testing we saw in the MV switchgear document [cite: 1]) and preventive maintenance programs. This falls under "Maintenance and Inspection."

  • Control and Alarm Systems: Utilizing control systems and alarms ("Control, Alarm & Shutdown System" and "Alarm & operator intervention") to maintain stable operations and alert personnel to deviations.

  • Safety Instrumented Systems (SIS): Implementing automated safety systems like Emergency Shutdown (ESD) to prevent hazardous situations from escalating ("Safety instrumented system").

  • Management of Change (MOC): Rigorously reviewing and controlling any changes to processes or equipment to prevent unintended safety consequences ("Management of Change").

  • Training and Competency: Ensuring that personnel have the necessary knowledge and skills to perform their tasks safely and effectively ("Training & Competency").



Mitigation: Limiting the Consequences


Despite our best preventative efforts, sometimes things can still go wrong. That's where mitigation comes in, aiming to reduce the impact of an incident:


  • Emergency Response Planning: Having well-defined and practiced plans to respond effectively to incidents ("Plant emergency response layer").

  • Physical Barriers: Implementing measures like dikes to contain spills ("Dike").

  • Pressure Relief and Fire & Gas Systems: Utilizing relief valves, rupture disks, and fire and gas detection/suppression systems to control and respond to specific hazards ("Relief valve, rupture disk, F&G system").



The Importance of Both


A truly effective safety strategy doesn't rely solely on prevention or mitigation. It requires a balanced approach where strong preventative measures reduce the likelihood of an incident, and robust mitigation measures minimize the potential consequences if one does occur.


As the text highlighted, this is a shared responsibility, guided by thorough risk assessment. By understanding the potential hazards and their risks, we can strategically implement layers of both prevention and mitigation to create a safer operating environment in asset-intensive and potentially hazardous industries.





What are your thoughts on the balance between prevention and mitigation in AIM and PSM? Share your insights below.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Understanding LV Earthing Systems: TT, TN, and IT Explained

By
Understanding LV Earthing Systems: TT, TN, and IT Explained Earthing systems are crucial for electrical safety, protecting people and equipment from faults and shocks. In low-voltage (LV) installations, the IEC 60364 standard defines three main earthing systems:  TT, TN, and IT , each with distinct characteristics and applications. This blog post explains these systems, their subtypes, and key safety considerations, referencing the attached technical screenshots for clarity. 1. Classification of LV Earthing Systems Earthing systems are identified by a  two-letter code : First Letter: Neutral Connection T (Terra)  – Neutral is  directly earthed  at the transformer. I (Isolated)  – Neutral is  not earthed  or connected via high impedance (≥1000 Ω). Second Letter: Equipment Earthing T  – Frames are  locally earthed , independent of the neutral. N  – Frames are  connected to the neutral , which is earthed at the transformer. 2. Typ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Understanding Short-Circuit Analysis with ETAP and the IEC 60909 Standard

By
U nderstanding Short-Circuit Analysis with ETAP and the IEC 60909 Standard Introduction: Short-circuit analysis is a critical aspect of electrical power system design and safety. It involves calculating the magnitude of fault currents to ensure the proper selection of protective devices and to verify that equipment can withstand fault conditions. This post will discuss how ETAP software performs short-circuit analysis in compliance with the IEC 60909 standard, a key standard in this field. Why is IEC 60909 Important? The IEC 60909 standard provides a globally recognized framework for calculating short-circuit currents in AC power systems. [Ref: IEC 60909-0:2016] Its importance stems from several factors: Ensuring Safety: Accurate short-circuit calculations, as mandated by IEC 60909, are crucial for selecting appropriately rated protective devices (circuit breakers, fuses) that can safely interrupt fault currents. [Ref: Short Circuit Analysis (IEC 60909 Standard) : Extent & Requir...
1 comment
Read more

Understanding Short-Circuit Calculations in Electrical Systems

By
U nderstanding Short-Circuit Calculations in Electrical Systems Introduction: Short-circuit calculations are fundamental to the design, protection, and safety of electrical systems. Determining the magnitude of fault currents allows engineers to select appropriate protective devices (like circuit breakers and fuses), ensure equipment can withstand fault conditions, and ultimately safeguard personnel and property. This post will explore some of the key equations, formulas, and underlying principles involved in these crucial calculations. Key Concepts and Equations: When performing short-circuit calculations, several factors and formulas come into play. Here are some essential ones: Transformer Impedance: It's important to note that transformer impedance is often based on the transformer's self-ventilated rating (e.g., the OA base is used for ONAN/ONAF/OFAF transformers). Voltage Notation: Throughout these calculations, line-to-line voltage in kilovolts is represented as (kV)...
1 comment
Read more